FA Trophy
Season Winner / R-up Name Surname Chr Name Club Date Opponents Att Result Notes
1971/72 Winner Peter Barlow Barlow Peter Stafford Rangers 15/04/1972 Barnet - 3 - 0  
1973/74 Runner-up Danny Light Light Danny Dartford 27/04/1974 Morecambe 19,000 1 - 2 -
1990/91 Winner Keith Scott Scott Keith Wycombe Wanderers 11/05/1991 Kidderminster Harriers 34,842 2 - 0 Scored goal
1991/92 Winner Scott Barrett Barrett Scott Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Gary Bennett Bennett Gary Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Replaced Roy McDonough after 64 minutes
1991/92 Winner Eamonn Collins Collins Eamonn Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Unused Substite. He handed his winner's medal to Jason Cook who was sent off during the game and did not receive one.
1991/92 Winner Jason Cook Cook Jason Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Started game. Sent off on 81 mins. Refused Winners medal, but Eamonn Collins hand him his.
1991/92 Winner Warren Donald Donald Warren Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Tony English English Tony Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Mark Kinsella Kinsella Mark Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Roy McDonough McDonough Roy Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Replaced by Gary Bennett after 64 minutes
1991/92 Winner Steve McGavin McGavin Steve Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game and scored 3rd goal after 89 minutes
1991/92 Winner Dave Martin Martin Dave Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Mike Masters Masters Mike Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game and scored 1st goal after 5 mins
1991/92 Winner Paul Roberts Roberts Paul Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game
1991/92 Winner Nicky Smith Smith Nicky Colchester United 10/05/1992 Witton Albion 27,806 3 - 1 Full game & scored 2nd goal after 19 minutes
1992/93 Winner Keith Scott Scott Keith Wycombe Wanderers 09/05/1993 Runcorn 32,968 4 - 1 Full game
1994/95 Runner-up Mark Yates Yates Mark Kidderminster Harriers 14/05/1995 Woking - 2-1aet  
1998/99 Winner David Leworthy Leworthy David Kingstonian 15/05/1999 Forest Green Roves 20,037 1 - 0 replaced by Delton Francis
1998/99 Winner Geoff Pitcher Pitcher Geoff Kingstonian 15/05/1999 Forest Green Roves 20,037 1 - 0 Full game (MOTM)
1999/2000 Winner David Leworthy Leworthy David Kingstonian 13/05/2000 Kettering Town 20,034 3 - 2 Replaced Junior Kadi
1999/2000 Winner Geoff Pitcher Pitcher Geoff Kingstonian 13/05/2000 Kettering Town 20,034 3 - 2 Full game
2000/01 Winner Neil Gregory Gregory Neil Canvey Island 13/05/2001 Forest Green Roves 10,001 1 - 0 Villa Park
2002/03 Winner Matt Taylor     Burscough 18/05/2013 Tamworth 14,296 2 - 1 Villa Park. Taylor arrived at Colchester as a defender - he won the FA Trophy as a goalkeeper!
2005/06 Runner-up Justin Richards Richards Justin Woking 14/05/2006 Grays Athletic 13,997 0 - 2 Full game
2009/10 Winner Andy Bond Bond Andy Barrow 08/05/2010 Stevenage Borough 21,223 2-1aet Full game