FA Trophy
Season	Winner / R-up	Name	Surname	Chr Name	Club	Date	Opponents	Att	Result	Notes
1971/72	Winner	Peter Barlow	Barlow	Peter	Stafford Rangers	15/04/1972	Barnet	-	3 - 0
1973/74	Runner-up	Danny Light	Light	Danny	Dartford	27/04/1974	Morecambe	19,000	1 - 2	-
1990/91	Winner	Keith Scott	Scott	Keith	Wycombe Wanderers	11/05/1991	Kidderminster Harriers	34,842	2 - 0	Scored goal
1991/92	Winner	Scott Barrett	Barrett	Scott	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Gary Bennett	Bennett	Gary	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Replaced Roy McDonough after 64 minutes
1991/92	Winner	Eamonn Collins	Collins	Eamonn	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Unused Substite. He handed his winner's medal to Jason Cook who was sent off during the game and did not receive one.
1991/92	Winner	Jason Cook	Cook	Jason	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Started game. Sent off on 81 mins. Refused Winners medal, but Eamonn Collins hand him his.
1991/92	Winner	Warren Donald	Donald	Warren	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Tony English	English	Tony	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Mark Kinsella	Kinsella	Mark	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Roy McDonough	McDonough	Roy	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Replaced by Gary Bennett after 64 minutes
1991/92	Winner	Steve McGavin	McGavin	Steve	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game and scored 3rd goal after 89 minutes
1991/92	Winner	Dave Martin	Martin	Dave	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Mike Masters	Masters	Mike	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game and scored 1st goal after 5 mins
1991/92	Winner	Paul Roberts	Roberts	Paul	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game
1991/92	Winner	Nicky Smith	Smith	Nicky	Colchester United	10/05/1992	Witton Albion	27,806	3 - 1	Full game & scored 2nd goal after 19 minutes
1992/93	Winner	Keith Scott	Scott	Keith	Wycombe Wanderers	09/05/1993	Runcorn	32,968	4 - 1	Full game
1994/95	Runner-up	Mark Yates	Yates	Mark	Kidderminster Harriers	14/05/1995	Woking	-	2-1aet
1998/99	Winner	David Leworthy	Leworthy	David	Kingstonian	15/05/1999	Forest Green Roves	20,037	1 - 0	replaced by Delton Francis
1998/99	Winner	Geoff Pitcher	Pitcher	Geoff	Kingstonian	15/05/1999	Forest Green Roves	20,037	1 - 0	Full game (MOTM)
1999/2000	Winner	David Leworthy	Leworthy	David	Kingstonian	13/05/2000	Kettering Town	20,034	3 - 2	Replaced Junior Kadi
1999/2000	Winner	Geoff Pitcher	Pitcher	Geoff	Kingstonian	13/05/2000	Kettering Town	20,034	3 - 2	Full game
2000/01	Winner	Neil Gregory	Gregory	Neil	Canvey Island	13/05/2001	Forest Green Roves	10,001	1 - 0	Villa Park
2005/06	Runner-up	Justin Richards	Richards	Justin	Woking	14/05/2006	Grays Athletic	13,997	0 - 2	Full game
2009/10	Winner	Andy Bond	Bond	Andy	Barrow	08/05/2010	Stevenage Borough	21,223	2-1aet	Full game